$1,500,000

About This Property

Prime Old San Carlos Boulevard Commercial Opportunity — The Window of Opportunity is Closing Now may be the time to secure one of the last remaining opportunities in the heart of Fort Myers Beach’s business district. With the vacant lot at 159/161 Old San Carlos Boulevard now under contract pending with contingencies, available commercial properties in this highly sought-after corridor continue to disappear. Don’t let this opportunity slip through your hands. This is one of the best-priced commercial properties currently available in the Downtown Core, offering exceptional value, redevelopment potential, and a motivated seller. Whether your vision is to rehabilitate the existing structure, reposition the property for immediate use, or pursue a complete redevelopment, 185 Old San Carlos Boulevard provides flexibility in one of the island’s fastest-growing commercial corridors. Located directly on iconic Old San Carlos Boulevard, this high-visibility site is just steps from Times Square, the Fort Myers Beach Pier, Crescent Beach Family Park, and Lynn Hall Memorial Park. Significant public and private investment continues throughout the district, including ongoing improvements to Crescent Beach Family Park, redevelopment activity surrounding Times Square, and continued enhancements to Lynn Hall Memorial Park. The area is experiencing renewed energy, increasing tourism, and strong long-term growth momentum.. Zoned Commercial Boulevard (CB), the property allows for a broad range of permitted uses including restaurant, bar, retail, office, residential, lodging, or mixed-use development. The existing structure presents an opportunity for immediate rehabilitation and activation, while the zoning and location support larger long-term redevelopment possibilities. Whether you’re envisioning a signature restaurant, vibrant entertainment venue, boutique retail destination, professional office, or multi-story mixed-use development, this location provides the visibility, traffic, and momentum needed for success. Location Description: Positioned within the high-traffic Downtown Core on Old San Carlos Boulevard, adjacent to Times Square, the Fort Myers Beach Pier, Crescent Beach Family Park, and Lynn Hall Memorial Park—an area experiencing substantial reinvestment, tourism growth, and long-term redevelopment momentum. Highlights: * Prime Downtown Core location * One of the lowest-priced commercial opportunities in the area * Commercial Boulevard (CB) zoning * Multiple permitted uses including residential, lodging, office, retail, restaurant, and mixed-use * Zero build-to-line requirements * Approximately 34 feet of frontage * Exceptional pedestrian and vehicle traffic counts * Steps to Times Square, the Pier, and Gulf beaches * Strong redevelopment and investment activity throughout the surrounding area * Motivated seller

infoProperty Details

Property Type

Multi-Family: Low Rise (1-3 Floors),Office: Business Park,Office: Office Building,Retail-Commercial: Free Standing Building,Retail-Commercial: Other,Retail-Commercial: Restaurant,Retail-Commercial: Retail Pad,Retail-Commercial: Street Retail,Special Purpose: Misc. Other

Year Built

1955

Lot Size

0.10 acres

Days on Market

208

List Date

Nov 17, 2025

Annual Taxes

$5K (2024)

yardExterior & Lot

Listed By

ERA Lahaina Realty

239-463-0000